Calls to Halt Arms Sales to Israel Called “Shallow Gesture Politics” by Tory MP
Calls to halt arms sales to Israel in the aftermath of the death of three British aid workers have been called “shallow gesture politics” by a Tory MP.
Calls to halt arms sales to Israel have sparked controversy in the UK following the tragic death of three British aid workers. Conservative MP Bob Seely, a member of the Foreign Affairs committee, dismissed these calls as "shallow gesture politics" and urged the UK to strengthen its ties with Israel.
The Government has come under increasing pressure to suspend arms sales to Israel after three British aid workers lost their lives in an attack by the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF). The World Central Kitchen (WCK) lost seven workers in Gaza, including Britons John Chapman, James “Jim” Henderson, and James Kirby.
WCK founder Jose Andres accused the Israeli military of deliberately targeting his aid workers, claiming they were tracked and attacked systematically. The incident prompted President Joe Biden to warn Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that future US support for Israel's actions in Gaza hinges on the protection of civilians and aid workers.
A letter signed by over 600 lawyers, including former Supreme Court justices, called for the UK to halt arms sales to Israel. Foreign Secretary Lord Cameron vowed that Israel would be held accountable for the attack on aid workers and emphasized unity with Prime Minister Rishi Sunak on the Gaza conflict.
Tory Divisions on Arms Sales
Tensions within the Conservative party have come to light as members express differing views on arms sales to Israel. Suella Braverman defended Israel, asserting that the country is not violating international humanitarian law. However, Sir Alan Duncan criticized Braverman's stance as extreme and advocated for consequences.
MP Bob Seely criticized those advocating for an end to arms sales, labeling their actions as "shallow gesture politics." He argued that the UK's arms exports to Israel make up a negligible percentage and called for a more substantive approach to the issue.
Seely urged the UK to strengthen its relationship with Israel and other involved Arab states, emphasizing the importance of maintaining influence through close ties. He highlighted the need for a strategic approach while balancing principles and national interests.
Government Under Pressure
The Government is facing demands to disclose legal advice amid concerns raised by civil servants within the Department of Business and Trade regarding potential legal liability related to arms exports to Israel. The PCS union has threatened legal action to protect its members from participating in unlawful activities.
Seely defended the Government's decision not to publish legal advice, stating that such practice is common and necessary. He pointed to previous instances involving countries like Saudi Arabia and Turkey, underscoring the delicate balance between principles and strategic relationships in the national interest.
As the debate over arms sales to Israel continues, the UK finds itself at a crossroads, grappling with moral obligations, diplomatic considerations, and strategic alliances. The path ahead remains uncertain, with diverging opinions and complex implications shaping the discourse.
Hey, I'm Fateh Muhammad, a Lahore local with a passion for arts and politics. My journey led me through the halls of the National College of Arts, where I delved into the intricacies of both disciplines. Now calling Lahore home, I'm here to share my insights and perspectives on the dynamic intersection of art and politics. Let's embark on this enlightening journey together! Connect With Me .